Category Archives: Dating a Saudi Student – also my Client

A Letter of Acceptance and Sorrow – Irony with Purpose

Is it a mere coincidence that my fate unfolded as it did? After I brutally discarded my ex-finace and broke his heart, I was met with the so-called fruits of life (wealth, praise, luck). Yet in an ironic twist, such ‘fruits’ didn’t bare any meaning in the long term. Is it a coincidence that another great man, the Sheik, came into my life…and isn’t it ironic how this great man can only ever be a temporary bliss? Is it ironic how I get all this admiration from numerous men, yet I am so deeply isolated in my thoughts and emotion? There is a reason for everything. I accept my fate.

heart

My mind comes backs to dear person I once met in my life. A short encounter, yet a meaningful encounter. He told me of an old idiom (from an unknown source). He said there are many disabilities that are not visible to the eye. For instance, we often view people with disabilities as someone who has a visible problem, such as being blind, handicap, etc. We look at these people and feel thankful that we are not in their condition. We pity them. Indeed these people endure hardships. But we also fail to look at disabilities that are not visible to the eye, such loneliness, pain, depression, hopelessness. There are many forms of pain, and suffering….and often they not visible or known. I do not pity myself. What I endure is something that I can, thankfully, manage. But my heart often cries for those who cannot manage. There are people with worse conditions who do not even protest or seek help……I wish those people all the best, for their courage. When I say I am suffering, I am not asking for help……I am thankful for this, ironically. Pain opens my eyes, to the light from the darkness.

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

If this is Your way of punishing me for the terrible things I did in the past, then I accept it. But I just ask, in perhaps a selfish way, of how much longer will I be punished? Perhaps I deserve it. Perhaps I don’t even deserve to know how much longer I must endure this suffering. But I know You did this for a reason, and I am so thankful for all the experiences in my life, both good and bad, because I know You are doing the best for me .

5 years ago, I met a met a man whom I deeply hurt. He was my lover, my life partner, a man who was the light to my darkness. He was like a Sufi poet, who was devout in his love. Like that of Akbar the Great Mughal Emperor and his love for his non-Muslim wife Jodha, he accepted me who for who I was. He had so much love in his heart, so much love to give. He asked for nothing in return. He only asked that I hold his heart in mine. He proposed that we make a family together, and stay together as husband and wife. So for almost 3 years, we lived like husband and wife being engaged, and we dreamt of having a family. Like any true lover, he sought to protect me. I saw how he truly would fight against his own life to keep me safe and protected. But those were ideal times. The reality is that I was full of darkness and hatred, and I introduced my sorrows into his honest heart.

My ego killed not only us, but it crushed his soul. I left him. I left him alone, without any emotional support. Yes, I had the ideal love, a man who gave up his life for me, lovingly and sincerely. A man who put me first. A man who accepted me as I am, and was willing to do whatever to protect me, fight for me. And suddenly, because of feeling I needed to ‘live my life’ I abandoned him.

The sad part of our story is that I was a selfish, egotistic person when I was with him. I took advantage of his love, his kindness and his generosity. I was dominant in our relationship, which he enjoyed. He made the money, he paid the bills, but it was me who decided what to do with the money. I made all the decisions, which didn’t bother him at all. Yet all the decisions were to benefit myself. I never thought of his needs, which his only need was that I keep him in my heart. I only thought of myself throughout our relationship. He tried so hard to please me. He cooked gourmet meals for me, he bought whatever I wanted, he made love to me to make sure I get pleasure in abundance and before his own, and he made every effort to enjoy the same hobbies as I, such as reading and writing. Yet despite his perfection, I was so blind. I criticized him, I put down his confidence, and I made him feel like he was worthless. If I deserve any punishment, the punishment should be severe. I deserve the worst for what I did.

So yes, I had a man who loved me more than himself, who moved across the world to start a life with me. And I left him. He invested money and everything he had into me, but mostly he invest his heart. His heart, which I broke and abandoned. After we seperated, he wrote to me beautiful letters. He would ask me to reconsider my decision – he asked me to come back to him

After I left him, I was quick to do whatever I wanted. I jumped right into another relationship, with the Sheik (like my ex, also a client). I had everything I thought I wanted: freedom to do whatever I want, a generous Khaleeji lover, all bills and expenses paid, generous amount of savings, my own place, etc. But then I realized how miserable I was. I traded a perfect man for a fake life, a life of insignificance. And what is the cause of all this? My ego. The very idea of needing to cater to myself is the biggest evil in my life. In the process of ‘bettering myself’ I neglected so many people – and inevitably I neglected myself in the end.

So I sit here, with money, material abundance…everything I thought I always wanted. But I realize how deeply unhappy I am, because I have nothing with true meaning. Material things give temporary happiness, but it brings zero meaningful or wholesome feelings. What is missing in my life are things that money cannot buy. The things I desire are family, good friendships and love. And to have a family with security and protection (something I didn’t have) I need to have marriage, to a good man — a good man that I once had, but I threw him away. So now I am being punished. Punished for my selfishness. And I deserve every tear that I’ve cried. I deserve every moment of loneliness and wondering if live is even worth living if I have to continue this way.

holding hands

The irony of it all, I have someone. I have my Sheik. Is it Your way of testing me? It this my punishment? Is it Your intention that another amazing, perfect man entered my life? And it is just a coincidence that he can never marry me or give me children? If so, I accept Your punishment. I accept my tears. My Sheik resembles my dear ex-fiance in that he does all that he can to please me, and does so lovingly and with sincerity. Bless his heart. Anything I need, he gives it with pleasure. The Sheik’s infamous words to me are, “Min Ayouni ya omry,” which min ayouni essentially means ‘from my eyes‘ in Arabic, or in English interpretation, “It would be my pleasure to do anything for you.” We cry in each others arms when we discuss our future. I swear to myself that I will leave him, and at times I’m often determined to do so. But the reality is I am so attached to him. Every part of my life has been incorporated with his life. Yet at the end of his studies, the truth will become reality: we can never be together.

I have tried to leave him, and I did so with full determination. But when I leave him, he will not let me go. He will come to my feet and kiss them. He will take my hands and say, “Slap me, hurt me…do whatever you want to me….but don’t leave me.” He feels the pain too, how can I punish him for something that pains him perhaps more? And lately, he says what I thought I wanted to hear: “I will marry you, we can have children.” He knows that’s what I want. He wants it too, and we talk about having a girl first. But there are too many politics that will result from making our love official.

I don’t want to imagine the consequences of our love. The consequences are only more pain and hurt. If our love remains, then we lose love in other ways. Our happiness will bring pain for others. How can I be selfish and ask for such a thing? If we get married, we must stay here (in the West). Staying here means that he will lose his family, his career. Staying here means our children will have only one set of grandparents, from my side. Staying here means we are isolated and alone from the loving arms of family members. Staying here means our child will grow up with an uncertainty of cultural traditions, because sadly my own culture has got contaminated by mainstream Western ideology. So I tell him, “No. I will never marry you and live here.” Do I want to raise my child in an environment where it’s ‘cool’ to be materialistic? Do I want my children to grow up without structure from a strong-knit family? No. It makes me saddened to imagine having a child experience the same life I did….the same circumstances and ideologies that indoctrinated me to believe that being  ‘independent’ and ‘sexy’ was something to embrace, when in reality it lead me into prostitution and money addiction.  There is no way I want to stay here, the West, in an isolated family. So the Sheik and I… we cry more, because hope is against us. There is no chance for us to be in Saudi either without hardships. Family acceptance is another hurdle, a hurdle that I understand. Although Saudi culture is rapidly changing and giving into Western ideology, I do understand the urgency to preserve whatever’s left of the ‘old’ ways.

So, I understand Your intentions. I just ask, please let this suffering be over, because I have learnt my lesson. For the past 2 years, I have understood my right from wrong, and Inshallah, I will change it, with Your help.

—————————————–

Leila and MajnoonI adore films and poetry. Many classic tales illustrate the pain of a forbidden relationship, such as the classic tale of Laila and Majnon in Persian/Indian/Arabic Folktales. An excellent Bollywood film that portrays such forbidden love is, “Veer Zaara,” where Veer and Zaara are very much like Laila and Majnon. The song below  (in 2 parts) from the film has powerful lyrics that illustrate the strength of love and sorrow. “Why is there a tradition of cruelty?”

“If I see your face, I will forget all my sorrows” — 2:33 seconds

12 Comments

Filed under Dating a Saudi Student - also my Client, Dealing with Depression, Memories, My Ex Fiancee - A former client, My Poetry, Relationships, The Sheik, Trying to Understand Why I Sell Myself

A Forbidden Relationship: Implications and Discussion

It’s not impossible, but barriers exist to discourage Saudi/non-Saudi couples from making a future together. The barriers are political and cultural. For one, Saudi students and Saudi men under the age of 35 cannot legally marry a foreign woman. By legally, I’m referring to a marriage that is legitimately recognized in Saudi Arabia. Culturally, most Saudis practice arranged marriages and thus the idea of marrying your ‘lover,’ especially a non-Saudi , is unfathomable. In some cases, these barriers can be overcome. For a Westerner, these political and cultural barriers can seem unjust. But now, I understand the purpose of these barriers. Why do they exist in the first place? What are the implications of a Saudi marrying a non-Saudi? I will aim to answer these questions.

Although envisaging our future is unbearable at times, I am gradually accepting the fate of my Sheik and I. Sometimes I convince myself that I’m going to leave him, but it’s not so easy to leave someone who is my protector. All the portrayals of Saudi men as womanizers and users of foreign women cannot apply to all Saudi men.  My Sheiks love is shown with sincere altruism. We both know our love will terminate in the near future. For now, all the barriers of society are things we ignore. He has treated me like his wife for quite some time now. He has made my life easier, and with his support I have the option to be away from a lifestyle that’s damaged me for years.

Arranged Marriage = Family Preservation

Saudi, or Khaleegy culture, is extremely beautiful in its traditional form, like all kinship societies. But unfortunately, these collectivist societies are under threat from dominant global ideologies.

Indeed, Saudi’s traditional tribal society is disappearing fast. Globalization had led to cultural imperialism of Western ideals, which permeates all political borders through television, internet, commerce, etc. In simple terms: the old culture is being replaced by Western values. Protection of cultural values is a big issue in an interconnected world. Many countries reject Western cultural imperialism. Many want to protect their cultures from the ills of Westernization (broken families, divorce, neglected children, etc). I empathize with this view. A strong family means children are not neglected, yet maintaining strong family ties is difficult in an individualistic society. How does this relate to marriage?

Marriage in kinship societies has symbolic meaning; it’s a means to facilitate social solidarity. Many Eastern cultures continue to practice arranged marriages. The purpose of the arranged marriage is not based solely on love, but rather on strengthening bonds between two families. In the case of exogamy (marrying outside the tribe), a man may marry a woman from another tribe to bridge solidarity between two tribes. In my case, my family used to practice arranged marriages, but we have all become individualistic and Westernized. Saudis, however, still practice arranged marriages, and the purpose is symbolic: to strengthen family ties among different tribes in the case of exogamy. Kin is essential for traditional societies like Saudi, and protecting kin is a big issue for them.

As much as one would want to feel pity for women in love with Saudis, we also must feel sympathy for the Saudi who genuinely loves a woman/man whom he/she cannot marry.

Hypothetically, what if I him and I got married?

Ideally, but only with full acceptance of the family. Yet what are the implications to our marriage? I have no tribe, and my family bonds are loose and erratic. I love my family, but unfortunately we lost our cultural significance and became, like many immigrants, consumed with the demands of Western life. A marriage between the Sheik and I will not unite his family and mine. An individual with no kin has little value to kinship cultures. I am a woman with no origins, and I belong nowhere. I long to be part of a large kin, to belong….yet membership is not easy because I lack the requirements: my own kin. At most, a woman like me can be designated only as a second wife, or temporary/misyaar wife (which I consider myself one now). Indeed, it hurts that I cannot belong, but I understand the meaning behind it. It makes sense: Saudis want to protect their kinship culture, and arranged marriage is essential to protect it as it creates social solidarity between two families/tribes. Yet the tragedy is that Saudi laws and customs that discourage/ban marriage-to-foreigners is not enough to preserve traditional society. Unfortunately, young Saudis are giving up their traditional ways for the more ‘attractive’ Western ones.

A Relationship Based Only on Love

The implications for Saudi/non-Saudi marriage is the loss of culture. There is no bonding of kins, or creation of social solidarity through marriage. The children of such a union will be mixed, which is embraced as ‘having the best of both worlds,’ but realistically mixed children cannot fully retain either culture. A marriage based solely on two people who love each other serves no benefit to the kin. Sociological studies say that ‘enduring love’ is an unrealistic expectation and marrying for the sole purpose of love has a high failure rate. A relationship based solely on love does not depend on input and strengthening of two families. And what exactly is love? Ideas of love can be unrealistic; the idea that love is enduring, (while in reality Sociological studies indicate that passion and romance in couples tends to decline after a two-year period). If love is all the relationship has, then how can the marriage survive ? For kinship societies marriage is based on more than just love,…it strengthens familial bonds too. The only people to benefit if the Sheik and I got married is him and I — it’s very isolated. Additionally, statistics indicated that love marriages compared with arranged marriages have a higher rate of divorce. Divorce impacts children, which impacts the family, which in the end breaks up the solidarity.

We cannot blame Saudi Men 

I noticed there is a lot of blame on Saudi men for their inability to take charge. Some say these men are weak, and if they were really ‘in love’ they would give up everything for a woman. That’s a Western way of thinking – me, me, me. Collectivistic cultures do not think of “me” but rather are “we” based. They will think, “What will benefit my family?” instead of “What benefits me?” I’m sure there are Saudi men who do use women and don’t tell their girlfriends that they have no intention of committing to them, but that is not exclusive to Saudis only. If anything, Saudis feel the pain just as strong. They are caught between two worlds, the traditional and the modern. They face tremendous pressure to satisfy the demands of family, society, religion and the outside world. Indeed they feel pain and hurt. One just needs to  listen to Saudi music or poetry to see there is a lot of pain expressed. I’ve observed countless music and arts that depict the pain of separation from their lover, the pain of being lonely, the pain of not being able to be with the one they love. This hurts them just as much.

I know my Sheik will suffer just as much pain, hurt and angst as I will when the time comes for our separation. I would never want my love to leave his family behind. It would be utterly selfish of me to ask him to join me in this individualistic world where family is NOT primary. Without family acceptance we would be isolated in our love, and that is not what I want.

For Saudis, family is everything, which is why it’s such a beautiful and admirable culture. And to preserve such beauty, we must try to understand why these barriers exist, even though it hurts.

8 Comments

Filed under Dating a Saudi Student - also my Client, Marriage

Being in Love and Escorting at the Same Time – Can’t Have Both

Being with a man I love and being a successful escort at the same time only works in theory. In reality, one or the other will be strained. For me, my work becomes strained. I cut down clients, because it’s harder to ‘tune’ out my emotions when I’m in love. Alternatively, if I put more emphasis in escorting than my relationship will be strained. I can’t have the best of both worlds.

Falling in love …it’s the worst thing for me as a sex worker. I become ‘stained.’ Stained, in a metaphorical way, in that my lover, the Sheik, has marked me (emotionally, physically, mentally). The love consumes me at every moment. I only want to be with my love, nobody else. As a result, I am lazy when with other men (clients).

When I’m in love, it’s like I become chemically ‘marked’ by  his love… his scent never leaves my skin. It’s as if his scent stays with me to ward off other men and say, “This woman is off-limits.” His scent is there when I am with clients. I have withdrawals from this special ‘scent’ when it’s not with me. And the clients can detect it: they know my heart, mind and soul belong to another man.

I become a lazy, uninterested and mechanical service provider to my clients when I am in love. This is the second time it has happened to me. It happened when I was in love with my ex, and I could no longer see clients because the idea of letting other men touch me was unimaginable. And now, with the Sheik…the same is happening. I barely work, but occasionally I see the odd client or two (my Sheik, of course, has no knowledge of this). It’s extremely difficult to sit there with a man who I have NO attraction too…and lay in his arms and be pleasant, because all I am thinking of is how much I hate it.

Yet I need the money. The Sheik provides for me…but I need to stay in the business to meet other goals. I don’t want to become too dependent on the Sheik — no no no — I must not rely on his money, or his love. Dependency is a dangerous area, which I don’t want to be in. Yet I can’t have the best of both worlds.

Sometimes, I wish it was easy just to abandon this love. But it’s not easy

6 Comments

Filed under Dating a Saudi Student - also my Client, Relationships, The Escorting Business, The Sheik

The Beginning of the End — But When?

It has now been over one year since we met.

The Sheik and I.

A few month ago, I tried a new angle to view our relationship: Live for today, because one cannot predict tomorrow. In other words, enjoy the moments now even though the future is undetermined. It sounded great in theory, but unfortunately reality kicks in.

I am starting to lose my mind. I have been suppressing all my emotions. Ensa al alam…we literally have forgotten the world, the realities of life in the recent months together. We are indeed happy and growing closer every day. As we get close, a part of me dies inside. Our growing love will equate to the growing hate that is to come.

Quarreling has began. I start it. I pour out all my emotions. Tears fall and our wet faces mash together in an emotional embrace. I have tried to be strong. I have tried to assert some power, but I have realized I am so weak. I tell him to leave….but he won’t leave me.

Our relationship has a shelf-life. There are a couple more years, and then it will expire. There is still a generous transaction that has existed the entire duration of our relation. I am grateful for it, but it sometimes feels insulting when money is used to compensate for a future. He knows I love him beyond my profession, yet I am still the courtesan. I used to think the monetary riches could compensate for the wholesome things he cannot give me (family, children, home), but no amount of money can save me from this pain. I could demand anything I want at this point, yet I don’t. What I want are not ‘things’..what I want is something beyond any material — I want our future.

And he loves ‘us’ now, because it’s convenient now. Yet ‘us’ in future tense can never be. Political barriers to our union, and cultural barriers. I could wait until the expiration date, and see how/if he fights against these barriers. But why should I hope when the odds are against us? Some say I should enjoy the moments now, but I crave the impossible. I crave a family’s blessings and family surroundings, and being surrounded by children. We are so deeply isolated in our love.

I watched a film recently. A French/Arabic film, titled “Rajah.” I cried immensely. The film depicts a hapless woman who is trying to leave her life as a prostitute. She wants to find ‘honest’ work, and she does. She yearns for ‘honest’ love too, and she gets that too. Only later, this ‘honest’ man turns out to be like the others – a man loving her while neglecting her of her dignity at the same time.

The Sheik loves me. I can end it, and suffer now. It is him who won’t stop the chase. Perhaps he knows my weakness, and he plays my addiction, or maybe not. When I threaten to bail, he panics. He can have any woman he wants, but he submits to all my desires and, ironically (being a Saudi male), he caters to me, the woman. He treats me with utmost importance, love, and respect. Is it a farce, or is it his helplessness?

My ex-fiance gave up his life to be with me, and I rejected him. He was eager to give me love, family, a home, and children. Now, I yearn for a future with a man who will never compromise his life for our love. I keep dreaming….a dream that has no destination.

2 Comments

Filed under Dating a Saudi Student - also my Client, The Sheik

The Difference Between Conditional and Unconditional Love

My ex-fiance was Muslim. He wasn’t devout, but he wasn’t too liberal either. He loved me unconditionally. How do I know? He accepted me for who I am. My ex wanted to marry me, and religion was not even a concern. His family was traditional. He would have faced objection to marrying a non-Muslim, but his love was stronger than this ‘pride.’ Thus, his love was unconditional. All the social stigmas that went against our union were ignored by him — he would cross any barrier to be with me.

On the other hand, with my love , the Sheik, religion has also not been a concern, ..yet. This time, there are numerous barriers to our union. The stigma of my profession. The stigma that I’m not Muslim. The stigma I am not Saudi..and even the stigma I’m not of the same tribe! I wonder, will he be like my ex? Is our love conditional or unconditional? For the present, it is unconditional…but what about the future?

I have always pondered that “if” question - how would I feel if my partner ASKED me to convert to Islam?:

If a man does not accept me for who I am (which is not easy considering the social stigmas attached to me) then the relationship will die. I can compromise for simple things, but not who I am. I have felt unconditional love, and therefore I will never accept anything less. If the day comes when someone asks me to convert my beliefs to conform to theirs…..I will be gone.

The arrogance of patriarchical customs. It reminds me of a cheesy Bollywood film  (Mission Kashmir) I watched which depicted an Indian Muslim man who married a Hindu woman. An outsider ridiculed the Muslim husband because he didn’t convert his wife. Defending himself, the Muslim husband said something along the lines of, “Why should I ask my wife to give up her faith for me? If anything, I would convert to her faith if that meant being with her” I found that scene very empowering. It reminds me of my Sheik, because he says, “I respect your beliefs just as you respect mine.” In essence, nobody (nor any faith) is either right or wrong.

Similarly, a woman I met preached constantly on how this is ‘haram’ and that is ‘halal’ while at the same time contradicting her own sayings. She went to the extreme of saying she wanted to revert to being a ‘virgin’ again, so that it would make her more ‘appealing’ to a ‘good’ Muslim husband. I don’t think she understood the concept of unconditional love, or somehow she convinced herself that she was unworthy of it. How can one love another who has set conditions for their love? If only we could seize judging others, and reflect on ourselves and what works for us. Rather than judge her, I actually felt bad for her. She, like myself prior, is too concerned with how others judge her…and in the process she forgets who she is. I hope she can stop worrying one day, because there is nothing bad, or ‘haram’, about the real her.

I have noticed that many non-Muslim women embrace the idea of converting to Islam for their Muslim partner. Are they really doing it for themselves? Or are they doing it fearing rejection if they don’t. For the ones doing it on the advice of their partner, I ask again, how can you love someone who has place conditions on your love?

2 Comments

Filed under Dating a Saudi Student - also my Client, Relationships, The Sheik

They say ..”Love is Stronger than Pride..”

Scars always remain…just like the stain on my veil will never go away. In this sense, I will always be a prostitute. Inshallah one day I will stop and do something that truly makes me happy, but regardless….I will always have a unique perspective on life that I cannot share with most.

I mentioned in previous posts how I conform to social norms in public settings. This society is not kind to those who do not conform. To avoid out-casting myself, I conform when I must. Sometimes, I have to pretend to be “sweet and innocent”…..when inside I’m feeling depressed and bitter about life.

Recently I had to be in the company of a group of normal women. When I say ‘normal’ I am referring to women who do not sell their bodies (and women who probably condemn the idea of prostitution). Of course, I am a master of disguise. I blend in well. I pretend to be like them, and share commonalities. But the truth is I am deeply damaged inside compared to these girls. To me, these girls come from stable families, and probably have great relationships with their Fathers.  I was introduced to these people by a client of mine, who has now become more of a friend. I enjoy meeting new people, but only for a short amount of time. If I can not be myself and feel comfortable, I’d rather avoid the situation. I prefer to be in company of people who know the ‘real’ me now.

On a personal note. I am deeply in love. The best things in life happen when one does not expect it. It has now been one year since the Sheik and I met. I cannot leave him. He is the first to greet me in the mornings and the last one to kiss me goodnight. We may not have the chance to share our life together forever, but we share our moments together now. He loves me, and I love him …and that’s all that matters. Our love has progressed with every kiss. In the past posts, I was always complaining about our love, but now I feel like saying “Alhamdolillah”….because I must be thankful….he has been a great addition into my life.

2 Comments

Filed under Dating a Saudi Student - also my Client, The Sheik